8 Steps to Interview Success: Insurance Underwriter

Insurance underwriter interview

Congratulations on getting an interview as an insurance underwriter! Insurance underwriting can be a very fulfilling and rewarding career. This article will help you prepare for your upcoming interview. It provides tips on questions to expect and questions to ask, skills the interviewer might be looking for and much, much more. Our goal – to increase your chance of getting this job and hopefully starting a life-long career in insurance.


Underwriter interview questions and much, much more!

When you thoroughly prepare for an interview, it shows the potential employer that you’re genuinely interested in the role and the company. It also demonstrates that you’re willing to put in the effort to succeed, which is a trait that employers value. Many job seekers don’t spend enough time preparing for interviews. This is your opportunity to stand out from other candidates who may not understand the role or the company as well as you do. 

This is your opportunity to showcase that you have the skills and strengths that your potential employer is looking for. You’ve got this.

8 Steps to a successful interview

Step 1 Understand the company

Research the company’s history, culture, and values. Examine their recent performance and any news or initiatives in which they have participated. You want to understand what the company is about and how they operate.

Step 2 Understand the role

Be clear about what the role of an underwriter entails at this specific company. Review the job posting in detail and note the required skills and responsibilities. Some of the important skills for insurance underwriters include the ability to 1) analyze, 2) make decisions, 3) communicate effectively, and 4) negotiate.

What does an insurance underwriter do?

Underwriters play a critical role in the insurance industry. They determine the terms and conditions of insurance policies and decide which applications should be accepted or rejected. This impacts not only the profitability of the insurance company but also the lives and businesses of policyholders.

The role of an underwriter involves a lot of analysis and decision-making. The job also requires clear communication, the ability to influence others, and big-picture thinking to reach mutually satisfactory agreements. It’s a role well-suited to those who enjoy problem-solving, critical thinking, and the application of knowledge in areas like finance, law, and business.  Moreover, insurance is a complex field that demands constant learning. Underwriters often specialize in a particular type of insurance, providing the opportunity to become a subject matter expert. The insurance industry is affected by changes in law, technology, and society, so there’s always something new to learn!

Read these articles to learn more  1) What is an Underwriter,  2) What is Insurance Underwriting.

Step 3 Understand how you fit

Reflect on how your skills, experiences, and career goals align with the role and the company. Be ready to provide examples from your academic or professional life that demonstrate you have the necessary skills and abilities. Also take care to illustrate your strengths in the way you conduct yourself during the interview, for example:

Show you can communicate effectively:
Understanding the role and the company allows you to tailor your responses to the interviewer’s questions more effectively. You can draw on specific experiences and skills that directly relate to the job requirements, showing the interviewer not only that you’re a good fit but also that you can communicate effectively.

 Ask insightful questions:
Your understanding of the role and the company will also help you formulate meaningful questions to ask the interviewer. Asking meaningful and impactful questions is a big part of an underwriter’s role.  This can impress the interviewer and also provide you with more information to decide if the job is right for you.

Prepare to show your negotiating skills:
Understanding the role and the company can also be beneficial if you receive a job offer. A deep understanding of the role’s responsibilities and the company’s culture and values will better equip you to negotiate salary, benefits, and other aspects of the job offer.

Step 4 Prepare your responses for common interview questions

While the specific questions asked may vary, here are some common questions that you should expect when interviewing for an underwriting position.

Insurance underwriter interview questions

      • Tell me about yourself
      • Why did you choose a career in insurance underwriting?
      • Can you describe a time when you had to analyze complex information to make a decision?
      • How do you manage your time and prioritize tasks?
      • How do you handle stressful situations or tight deadlines?
      • Can you explain a complex financial concept in simple terms?
      • Can you describe a time when you had to deal with a difficult client or colleague?

Step 5 Prepare questions to ask the interviewer

You should also prepare some questions to ask the interviewer to demonstrate your interest in the role and company. Here are some you might consider:

Questions to ask in an interview

      • How would you describe the company culture here?
      • What does a typical day look like for an underwriter at this company?
      • What are some of the challenges that someone in this role might face?
      • How does the company evaluate and measure performance?
      • What opportunities for professional development or advancement exist within the company?

Step 6 Practice!

Conduct mock interviews with friends or family members, or even in front of a mirror. This can help you refine your answers and be more comfortable during the actual interview.

Step 7 Prepare logistics

Know where and when the interview is, plan your route, and decide what you will wear. Make sure to bring copies of your resume and a list of references.

Step 8 Follow-up

After the interview, it’s a good practice to send a thank-you note to the interviewers. It shows your courtesy and keeps you on their mind after the interview.

Remember, every interview is a two-way street. The interviewer evaluates you, but you also evaluate them to determine if this company and role suit you. Underwriting isn’t just about crunching numbers. It’s also about understanding people, businesses, and risks, so let your personality shine!




Get prepared: What is an Underwriter
Learn more
: What is Insurance Underwriting
Make a planDownload a free career development plan template

Courses for insurance professionals
financial statements
Best Seller
1.5 Hours

Understanding Financial Statements for Insurance Professionals

Take the course! Learn to read and understand financial statements. Discover which ratios are important and how underwriters read the notes.
MS Excel for insurance
Best Seller
1.5 Hours

Managing Policy Renewals using MS Excel

Take the course! Learn to set up MS Excel using shortcuts, formulas and formatting; includes tips for easy ways to manage your insurance policy renewal portfolio.  
Gaining Business Insights using MS Excel Pivot Tables
1.5 Hours

Gaining Business Insights using MS Excel Pivot Tables

Take the course! Learn how to use the pivot table feature in MS Excel to interpret data such as renewal lists and account receivable reports. 
This is default text for notification bar