A Checklist to Successful Negotiations in a Hard Market

Hard market negotiations

Reading time: 3 Min.

After a decade of operating in a soft market, it seems that many of us are rusty on our negotiation skills. As brokers, we are now commonly underprepared for negotiations with insurance carriers in the hardening market because being a great negotiator requires lots of practice. With the turn of the market, we’re now finding ourselves struggling to succeed in negotiations on time. As a result, we’re left spinning our wheels, short on time for processing unnecessary coverage extensions, with unhappy clients and resentful trading partners.

Review the following checklist before entering any critical negotiation. These questions will help you analyze your perspective and think on your feet when coming into discussions.

  1. What are my short term and long term objectives from the negotiation? Make a list ranging from the minimum viable acceptable offer to a dream case scenario.

  2. What is my BATNA (best alternative to a negotiated agreement)? In other words, do you have any other options should you be unable to strike a deal?

  3. What are the strengths of my client and risk profile? Think beyond the application, such as client history, risk management, and management team.

  4. What are the weaknesses of my client and risk profile? Don’t be caught blinded sided by the underwriter. Know the good, the bad, and the ugly better than anyone else.

  5. Why is the other party negotiating with you? What do you have that may be of interest to the underwriter? What is the underwriter getting out of the deal, and factors that would be beneficial for them?

  6. Do you have a list of questions for the underwriter? Knowledge is power. Arm yourself with questions that will strengthen your position for future talks with the same or other underwriters. Uncover the underwriter’s perspective and what tips the scale in your and their favour.

  7. Have you entered into a similar negotiation in the past? If so, think of benchmarking, alternatives, and precedents that can help support your case.

  8. Who else should be in your negotiating team? You are not alone. Is there anyone else at your office that has a strong relationship with the underwriter? What should be the responsibilities of each team member?

  9. Can you involve a third party to support your cases, such as claims department, lawyers, or even the client? The perspective of a third party may shine the light on other options or solutions.

  10. What is your relationship with the underwriter/ carrier? How might the past affect this negotiation? Are you prepared to leave emotions and personality issues separate from the negotiation?

  11. What are your assumptions going into the negotiation? Are any of these assumptions groundless and unfounded, and could these assumptions be taking you down a rabbit hole? An example – assuming that your client will be disappointed unless you get a flat renewal.
    Learn more about the insurance broker role: What is a broker?

  12. Are you aware of any anchoring traps that might affect your decision making or the underwriter’s decision making? Anchoring traps is when we give too much weight to information first received, such as an initial declination or high pricing.

  13. Have you considered all options for mutual gain? With a wide range of possible options, you are more likely to leave both the client and the underwriter in a win-win position.

  14. Will you be relying on negotiating through email? Are you prepared for the pros/cons of electronic messaging? Would a face to face or phone conversation result in a better outcome?

  15. Have you practiced communicating the message to the underwriter? What is your tone, and how are they likely to respond to it? Be cautious of sounding adversarial or defensive.

The key thing to remember is to take the time to prepare (be proactive, not reactive)! All negotiations are different and vary in difficulty level; however, if you know what you want, how to get there, and what might come up along the way, you’ll be in a much better position to achieve a positive result. And remember, a successful negotiation is a win-win for all parties, and an adversarial approach will not necessarily get you there.

There are plenty of different answers to the questions on the checklist for different situations, none necessarily right or wrong. Review the list before your next negotiation, and you’ll come out with a smile on your face!

Cyber Insurance
Best Seller
1.5 Hours

Cyber Insurance 101

$150.00
Take the course! Learn the fundamentals of Cyber Insurance. Discover how and why privacy and security breaches create exposures for companies and what coverage is available.
financial statements
Best Seller
1.5 Hours

Understanding Financial Statements for Insurance Professionals

$150.00
Take the course! Learn to read and understand financial statements. Discover which ratios are important and how underwriters read the notes.
MS Excel for insurance
Best Seller
1.5 Hours

Managing Policy Renewals using MS Excel

$150.00
Take the course! Learn to set up MS Excel using shortcuts, formulas and formatting; includes tips for easy ways to manage your insurance policy renewal portfolio.  
Technology Errors & Omissions Insurance
1.5 - 2 Hours

Technology Errors & Omissions Insurance 101

$150.00
Take the course! Learn the fundamentals of Technology Errors and Omissions insurance and the different coverage options available for technology product and service providers.
Gaining Business Insights using MS Excel Pivot Tables
Popular
1.5 Hours

Gaining Business Insights using MS Excel Pivot Tables

$150.00
Take the course! Learn how to use the pivot table feature in MS Excel to interpret data such as renewal lists and account receivable reports. 
EPLI Employment Practices Liability Insurance
Popular
2 Hours

Employment Practices Liability Insurance 101

$150.00
Take the course! Learn the fundamentals of EPLI: when do organizations need it, how does it work, what are the key exposures and coverage options; plus current trends and issues.
Customer Service instructors
Best Seller
1.5 Hours

Strategies for Delivering Bad News in Insurance

$150.00
Take the course! Master the art of customer service in insurance. Learn strategies for delivering bad news effectively. Boost client satisfaction and reduce stress.
Ethics and client relations
1.5 Hours

Navigating Ethical Dilemmas in Client Relations

$150.00
Take the course! Learn how to navigate ethical dilemmas in client relations. Get an ethical decision making framework and earn insurance CE/CPD credit.
Ransomware and Insurance course
1.5 Hours

Ransomware and Insurance

$150.00
Take the course! Learn all about ransomware insurance; what is ransomware, what happens during an attack and when insurance will pay, etc.
fiduciary liability insurance
Popular
2 Hours

Fiduciary Liability Insurance

$150.00
An important course for every pension plan and employee benefit program fiduciary – administrators, trustees and sponsors, as well as insurance and legal professionals. Learn about risks, policy structure, claims, risk mitigation and how to buy.
Miscellaneous Professional Liability
Popular
2 Hours

Miscellaneous Professional Liability Insurance Fundamentals

$150.00
Miscellaneous Professional Liability Insurance – a critical course for every professional or professional services organization as well as for those who support and guide them. Learn about risks, key coverages, claims, risk mitigation and how to buy.
Directors and Officers Liability Insurance
Popular
2 Hours

Directors & Officers Liability Insurance 101

$150.00
Take the course! Learn the fundamentals of D&O liability, indemnification, policy structure, claims and more.
Not for profit directors and officers liability insurance course
Popular
2 Hours

Not-for-profit Directors and Officers Liability Insurance

$150.00
Take the course! A valuable resource for every director and officer of a not-for-profit organization and those who support and guide them. 
Ransomware and cyber extortion
Free

2022 Market Update Ransomware and Insurance

Free short course, ebook and other resources about the evolution of ransomware and how the insurance market is responding.
crime insurance
Popular
1.5 Hours

Commercial Crime Insurance Fundamentals

$150.00
Take the course! Learn the fundamentals of commercial crime insurance: what’s covered and what’s not, how policies are structured, what to expect when there is a claim, and more...