Understanding Silent Cyber Risk

Understanding Silent Cyber Risk

Silent cyber risk is the risk that a traditional insurance policy may cover cyber-related losses the insurer did not intend to cover. This can happen when the loss falls within the policy’s existing coverage and no exclusion clearly removes that coverage. The result is that the insurer may face claims for a risk it never priced into the premium, while the insured may find its expected protection in dispute. Resolving that dispute can delay payment and add costs for both parties.

This article examines how silent cyber risk arises, its consequences for insurers and insureds, and how brokers can help clients identify unclear coverage and address potential gaps.

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    What is silent cyber risk?

    ‘Silent cyber’, also known as non-affirmative cyber, refers to potential cyber-related losses under traditional insurance policies where coverage has not been explicitly addressed through clear policy wording. These exposures may result in coverage that insurers did not intend to provide or did not adequately account for when pricing the policy.

    Unlike silent cyber, affirmative cyber coverage expressly addresses cyber-related risks in the insurance policy. This coverage may be provided through a dedicated cyber insurance policy or through specific provisions in a traditional insurance policy. However, affirmative coverage does not mean that every cyber-related loss is insured. Coverage remains subject to the policy’s terms, conditions, exclusions, and limits.

    Businesses bought property and liability insurance long before they connected their machinery, records, and everyday operations to computer networks. These insurance policies covered familiar losses, such as fire damage from a lightning strike and claims from customers who suffered injuries in a slip and fall.

    Connected technology introduced new ways for losses to occur. A hacker can now damage equipment by remotely interfering with its controls. An employee’s computer error can disrupt a service and cause a customer to lose money.

    And the changes keep coming. Businesses connect more equipment, adopt new systems, and rely on more technology providers. Attackers find new weaknesses to exploit. Each development can introduce new ways for losses to occur.

    Insurers face the ongoing challenge of writing policy wordings that address these evolving risks when they cannot predict every form those risks will take.

    For example, a property policy may cover fire damage without clearly addressing fires caused by cyberattacks. Suppose a hacker interferes with a factory’s machinery, causing it to overheat and catch fire. The insurer may not have intended to cover damage resulting from a cyberattack. However, the policy may still cover the fire damage if it meets the policy’s coverage terms and no exclusion rules it out. The fact that a cyberattack started the fire does not, by itself, settle whether the insurer must pay. This lack of clarity about cyber-related coverage is silent cyber.

    Silent cyber risk arises when policy wording leaves an insurer potentially facing cyber-related claims it did not intend to cover or price into the premium. The insured may expect payment, while the insurer disagrees about whether or not the policy covers the claim. Whether the policy responds depends on its terms, the circumstances of the loss, and applicable law. An insurer’s failure to anticipate or price a cyber-related exposure does not, by itself, eliminate coverage.

    Why cyber exposure can go unnoticed

    Businesses often associate cyber risk with stolen data or ransomware. Yet, their cyber exposure can actually extend much further. For example, given how connected many businesses are, a cyber incident can also damage equipment, stop production, or interrupt services to customers.

    Businesses may overlook these kinds of losses when they discuss each type of insurance separately. When buying property insurance, a client and broker might discuss fires and storms without considering how a cyberattack could damage the same buildings or equipment. When buying cyber insurance, they might focus on stolen data and ransomware. As a result, they may never check which policy, if any, would cover equipment damage caused by a cyber incident.

    Silent cyber exposure is not limited to property insurance. It can also arise under commercial general liability, professional liability, directors and officers liability, crime, and other traditional insurance policies. For example, a cyber incident could lead to third-party bodily injury or property damage claims, allegations of professional negligence, or claims against directors and officers. Whether these losses are covered depends on the terms of the relevant policy. For more information about third-party exposures, see our article on liability coverage in a cyber policy.

    Brokers can help by starting with what could go wrong in the client’s business, then examining how its policies might respond to each loss.

    Those discussions should include accidental events as well as deliberate attacks. Cyber-related losses can result from malicious acts, such as hacking or ransomware, as well as non-malicious incidents, such as employee errors or system failures. However, insurance policies may treat these events differently. For example, a policy may cover losses caused by a malicious cyberattack but exclude certain losses resulting from accidental system failures, or vice versa. Brokers should examine how each policy defines and addresses these different events.

    Silent cyber risk for the insured

    The insured needs to understand which losses insurance may cover and which the business may have to fund itself.

    If the insurer disputes coverage, both parties could spend time and money resolving the disagreement. In the interim, the business may need to pay for repairs and recovery in addition to ongoing operating costs. If the policy ultimately does not cover the loss, the business will bear costs that it expected the insurer to pay. These recovery expenses may also be relevant when considering first-party cyber insurance.

    To reduce the chance of these surprises, the insured also needs to consider silent cyber risk when buying insurance. With its broker, the business should examine how different policies may respond to cyber-related losses, ask insurers to clarify unclear wording, and explore coverage options for potential gaps.

    Once the business understands what its insurance may cover, it can better plan how to fund losses that fall outside that protection and costs it may need to pay while awaiting a claim decision.

    The practical question for the client is: if this cyber-related loss occurs, how much could the business have to pay, and could it afford that amount?

    Silent cyber risk for the insurer

    For the insurer, a central concern is paying claims for cyber risk it did not price into the premium. In its 2021 Cyber Risk Toolkit, the American Academy of Actuaries identifies two major aspects of silent cyber risk: unintended coverage and unpriced coverage.1

    These issues are related, but they are not identical. Unintended coverage arises when a policy may respond to cyber-related losses that the insurer did not intend to insure. Unpriced coverage arises when the insurer has not adequately reflected the cyber exposure in its pricing. These exposures may overlap, but they are not necessarily the same.2 In either case, the insurer must look to the policy wording to determine coverage. If the policy wording covers a cyber-related loss, the insurer cannot deny the claim simply because it did not charge for that risk.

    Insurers also face aggregation: one cyber incident can trigger claims from many policyholders and across different types of insurance, such as property, liability, and business interruption insurance, creating substantial combined losses.3

    Reinsurance, the insurance insurers buy for themselves, can create an additional financial risk when its coverage does not match the insurer’s own policies. Differences in exclusions, definitions, coverage limits, or policy conditions can result in an insurer covering a cyber-related loss without receiving the reinsurance protection it expected. For example, if a reinsurance contract excludes cyber losses that the insurer’s own policies cover, the insurer may have to pay more of the loss itself.

    How brokers can identify silent cyber exposure

    Brokers can help clients examine how their operations, potential losses, and insurance fit together. A practical review starts with a few realistic scenarios.

    1. Start with the client’s business

    A broker should ask how the client uses technology and what could happen if someone interferes with it or makes a mistake. Using the factory example introduced earlier, consider what could happen if a hacker interferes with machinery controls, an employee makes an error when updating a control system, or a cyber incident stops a critical supplier from making deliveries. The supplier scenario may also raise questions about contingent business interruption insurance.

    For each scenario, the broker and client should identify the losses the business could face: damaged equipment, lost income, extra operating costs, or claims from customers.

    2. Examine the policies that might respond

    A broker should review which of the client’s insurance policies may respond to each loss, considering the insuring agreements, definitions, exclusions, conditions, and applicable endorsements. This means reading each policy to check what it covers, how it defines key terms, what it excludes, and what conditions the insured must meet for the policy to cover the loss. The broker should also review any endorsement that amends the policy’s terms.

    Just because a policy references cyber does not necessarily mean that it covers a cyber-related loss. Some policies have clauses that begin with a broad exclusion, then restore coverage for specified losses. The broker needs to read the whole clause alongside the rest of the policy, checking how the policy defines key terms and how the different parts of the policy work together.

    When drafting sample policy wording for cyber-related losses, the Lloyd’s Market Association tests the wording against loss scenarios to check whether it provides the intended coverage.4 Brokers can use the same approach when reviewing clients’ policies to identify unclear coverage and potential coverage gaps.

    3. Clarify and explain the findings

    After reviewing how the client’s policies might cover the identified loss scenarios, the broker should follow up on any questions about coverage. This means asking the insurer to clarify how the policy would respond to each specific loss scenario. However, an insurer’s informal explanation does not necessarily change or override the policy’s terms. If the client and insurer agree that particular coverage should apply, the broker should ensure that the agreement is reflected in the policy wording, which may require an endorsement.

    The broker should then explain the coverage and any remaining unresolved questions to the client. If coverage gaps remain, they can discuss options such as seeking coverage from another insurer, buying additional insurance, improving risk controls, or choosing to fund certain losses. Throughout the process, the broker should record the advice, the alternatives discussed, and the client’s decisions.

    When policy terms change

    A policy amendment can change the insurance response even when the business itself stays the same. An insurer may introduce wording that expressly covers cyber-related losses, excludes them, or provides limited protection. A clear exclusion can resolve a question about coverage while leaving the client with a loss to fund elsewhere.

    A silent cyber exclusion is a policy provision intended to clarify or remove coverage for certain cyber-related losses under a traditional insurance policy. Some exclusions contain exceptions, often called write-backs, that restore coverage for specified losses. For example, a property policy might exclude certain cyber-related losses while preserving coverage for physical damage caused by a resulting fire. The scope of any exclusion or exception depends on its wording.

    In recent years, insurers and insurance markets have increasingly introduced policy wording that expressly includes or excludes cyber-related losses. For example, Lloyd’s introduced requirements beginning in 2020 to clarify how cyber risks are treated in certain insurance policies. However, these provisions vary between insurers and policies, and their application to particular losses may still require careful review.

    At renewal time, the broker should revisit the client’s loss scenarios and compare the expiring and proposed policy terms. The client needs to understand what has changed and how those changes could affect its insurance purchases and financial planning.

    For example:

    • Does the new wording change how the policy treats equipment damage or lost income?
    • Does an exclusion remove coverage the client previously relied on or expected?
    • Does an exception restore any coverage, and what conditions or limits apply?
    • Could another policy cover losses that the new terms leave uninsured?

    Looking again at our factory example, a useful explanation for this client would identify how the proposed wording affects a fire caused by an attack on its control system. Simply telling the client that the policy now contains a cyber exclusion provides too little information for a business decision as it does not explain which losses the business may have to fund itself.

    Dedicated cyber insurance may help address certain coverage gaps, but brokers must review its terms alongside the client’s existing policies. Cyber policies do not necessarily cover physical property damage, bodily injury, or all forms of business interruption. The broker should identify which losses each policy may cover and where gaps or limitations remain.

    When the situation changes

    Brokers also need to revisit the discussion when the client makes changes in its operations. Connecting machinery to a network, outsourcing a critical process, or adopting a new system can introduce new ways for a cyber incident to cause loss. The broker and client will need to examine how the existing policies would respond to the new loss scenarios.

    Questions to guide a coverage review

    Five questions can guide the review:

    1. What cyber-related events could cause significant losses for this client?
    2. Which policies might respond to each loss, and what wording supports that assessment?
    3. Where do the policies clearly provide or exclude coverage, and where do questions remain?
    4. What has changed in the business or its policies since the last review?
    5. Which remaining exposures will the client insure, reduce through risk controls, or fund itself?

    Frequently Asked Questions About Silent Cyber Insurance

    What is the difference between silent cyber and affirmative cyber coverage?

    Silent cyber, also known as non-affirmative cyber, refers to potential cyber-related losses under traditional insurance policies where coverage has not been explicitly addressed. Affirmative cyber coverage, on the other hand, expressly addresses cyber-related risks through a dedicated cyber insurance policy or specific provisions in a traditional policy. However, affirmative coverage does not mean that every cyber-related loss is insured. Coverage remains subject to the policy’s terms, conditions, exclusions, and limits. Learn more about how cyber insurance works.

    Which types of insurance policies may contain silent cyber exposure?

    Silent cyber exposure can arise under several types of traditional insurance policies, including commercial property, commercial general liability, professional liability, directors and officers liability, and crime insurance. For example, a cyber incident could cause physical property damage, interrupt business operations, or result in claims against a company’s directors and officers. Whether a policy responds depends on its wording and the circumstances of the loss. Cyber-related business interruption losses also require careful consideration of coverage triggers, exclusions, and limits. Learn more about business interruption coverage in cyber insurance.

    Does a cyber exclusion mean all cyber-related losses are excluded?

    Not necessarily. A cyber exclusion may remove coverage for certain cyber-related losses while preserving coverage for others. Some exclusions contain exceptions, often called write-backs, that restore coverage for specified losses. For example, a property policy might exclude certain cyber-related losses but preserve coverage for physical damage caused by a resulting fire. Brokers and insureds should review the entire exclusion, including its definitions and exceptions, alongside the rest of the policy to understand which losses may still be covered.

    Key takeaways

    • Silent cyber refers to unclear treatment of cyber-related losses in insurance policy wordings.
    • The insured and insurer may disagree about whether or not the policy covers a claim.
    • Insurers may face claims for cyber risks they did not anticipate or adequately price.
    • Brokers should help clients identify unclear coverage, understand potential gaps, and decide how to manage the losses they may have to fund themselves.

    Sources

    1. American Academy of Actuaries, Silent Cyber, Cyber Risk Toolkit, August 2021, pp. 2–3. ↩
    2. Ibid., p. 3. ↩
    3. Ibid., p. 2. ↩
    4. David Powell, “The challenge of clarity: cyber risks and policy language“, Lloyd’s Market Association, 28 September 2021, #5–6. ↩

    Related Articles

    Courses to explore
    Cyber Insurance 101
    Best Seller
    1.5 hours

    Cyber Insurance 101

    This is not your typical Cyber 101. A comprehensive course for anyone who wants to take their knowledge beyond the basics. Learn what standalone policies cover, how breaches lead to claims, and how to compare coverage. Includes real-world scenarios and key insights for today’s cyber landscape.